Who let the Pope out? Who, who, who?
BQB here with a review of this surprise hit.
This movie reminds of many an Aaron Sorkin film that takes you “behind the scenes.” Behind the scenes in the halls of congress. Behind the scenes of a TV show. Behind the scenes of the I Love Lucy show, or here, behind the scenes of the papal election process. Luckily for us viewers, Aaron Sorkin wasn’t involved because like his films, this one is very heavy on the dialogue but unlike in his films, the dialogue is believable and digestible.
The pope has passed and Cardinal Lawrence, the Dean of the College of Cardinals (Ralph Fiennes) is tasked with the duty of running the conclave, that most secretive of procedures in which cardinals from all over the world gather behind closed doors at the Vatican, are sequestered, cut off from all contact and news from the outside world until they reach a majority vote on who the next Pope will be.
They must choose one of their own ranks and though they are supposed to have lived holy lives, each carries baggage that threatens to undo their candidacy. At least the frontrunners do. They are human, after all.
Frontrunners include members of warring factions – the liberals Bellini (Stanley Tucci) and Tremblay (John Lithgow) fear the Catholic Church will go backward under conservative Tedesco (Sergio Castellito). Cardinal Adeyemi of Africa (Lucien Msamati) has enough support to potentially become the first pope of color while dark horse candidate Benitez (Carlos Diehz) has just become known to his brothers under mysterious circumstances. The late pope had granted him leadership of the archdiocese of Kabul, Afghanistan in secret for fear that going public would have led to the demise of Benitez and any Catholics under his watch in a lawless, radical Muslim country.
Tedesco is portrayed as a scene chewing villain though if you’re a conservative, you’ll think he has a point or two. I know I did, but anyway.
Isabella Rosselini plays Sister Agnes, the head nun at the Vatican. Her ranks are usually seen and not heard though she has important info to share.
Speaking of info, Lawrence is burdened with the task of rooting out corruption and boy, there’s a lot of it. He does this with a heavy heart because a) he’s suffering a crisis of faith b) he sees all of the cardinals as his brothers and does not like politics and muckraking and c) there are ancient rules about what can and can’t be done vis a vis information found that he must navigate through. One by one, each frontrunner is faced with a scandal that threatens their undoing and Lawrence, who would rather not have the job, must sus out the deets of chicanery perpetrated by his colleagues. Even worse, he becomes a frontrunner himself due to his track record of good behavior. That would be good news for any other cardinal but not for Lawrence, because he really doesn’t want the job. He’s not sure if he even wants his current job anymore.
The good? This movie is part mystery and part political intrigue thriller. The frontrunners are set up like so many dominos only to be knocked down. It seems a miracle that any man could be elected to such a holy office, given that the slightest act of human infallibility can lead to a candidate’s undoing.
What could this movie have done better?
A) You don’t always get the answers to some of the mysterious questions posed. The actions of various cardinals are questioned. The cardinals defend themselves and claim the accusations are outrageous. Sometimes you get the definitive smoking gun that shows said cardinal is full of crap. But as often happens in life, sometimes the question is left unanswered. Maybe the cardinal under examination was a scumbag or maybe they are unfairly maligned. The truth doesn’t always get presented with a gift wrapped bow.
B) Ralph Fiennes delivers an Oscar worthy performance, one of many in his long career. But while he portrays a good man who must complete a task that fills him with anxiety but does it with honor, we’re never told the events of his personal life that caused him to have a crisis of faith. We just know that he doesn’t like the politics of the Vatican, would prefer to run an archdiocese somewhere, anywhere else, but the Pope thought he was too good as a “manager” to let him leave the position.
STATUS: Shelf-worthy. Obviously, there’s no action packed CGI here, but if you’re interested in the intrigue of Vatican City, this movie is for you.