Hey 3.5 readers.
Welcome to another “Pop Culture Mysteries: Behind the Scenes,” the only column where I, Bookshelf Q. Battler, ask random Internet folk for writing advice because my friends and family are such that they’ll laugh their asses off if I tell them that I’m helping a 95 year old private dick write his memoirs.
There’s been an issue in the back of the mind and it starts to come to the forefront in the Informant Zero story.
OK. Stay with me here.
- Jake is a writer for the Bookshelf Battle Blog.
- The Bookshelf Battle Blog exists in the Pop Culture Mysteries world. It has to, because Bookshelf Q. Battler bosses Jake around through his attorney, Delilah K. Donnelly.
- Ergo, won’t people, when they meet Jake, look up the Bookshelf Battle Blog and learn about Jake’s past and his special abilities (non aging, invincibility, etc)
Originally, I thought I’d go with that old cliche where the special hero doesn’t reveal his special-ness to people he meets. The vampire hides his fangs and blends in with the norms. Superman puts on a pair of glasses. Bruce Wayne pretends to be an do-nothing playboy.
Wait, let’s back up a minute.
THUS FAR, WHO KNOWS THAT JAKE IS A 95 YEAR OLD PRIVATE DICK?
- Ms. Tsang, obviously, because she took care of him while he was asleep for decades. Eventually, I’ll work it into the story how that burden really sucked for her and kept her from doing a lot of things she wanted to do in life, including starting a family, because, you know, how do you explain to people that there’s a gumshoe upstairs that just sleeps forever, never grows old and stays young?
- Delilah K. Donnelly and Bookshelf Q. Battler – Battler’s claim to be able to answer Jake’s question of why did he sleep for 60 years is the center point of the series. Battler knows, his trusted attorney Delilah knows, but they aren’t telling until 100 Pop Culture Mysteries are solved. (Or does Battler know – is he just yanking Jake’s chain for the unscrupulous purpose of bringing a writer with an interesting story to his blog?)
- Others from Jake’s Past, Who May or May Not Start Appearing in the Future, and If They Do, Only BQB and Delilah Will Know Why Past People are Showing Up in the Future – We’ll get to that. Mickey Finn (Jake’s old partner), first girlfriend Peaches, his three ex-wives and anyone else from the past is fair game to return to the future.
THUS FAR, WHO DOESN’T KNOW THAT JAKE IS A 95 YEAR OLD PRIVATE DICK? – Agnes Abernathy, aka Agnes the Librarian, is Jake’s unwilling research assistant. As a public librarian in a busy city library, she’s used to all types wandering in and bugging her to look stuff up for them. Hobos and bums often use the library as place to hang out and up until Fan Dime Drops, Agnes thought that Jake was another bum. She still thinks Jake is odd, but after seeing Delilah meet with Jake, she at least believes that Jake writes for the Bookshelf Battle Blog.
BUT – she has yet to realize that Jake is a 95 year old private dick.
BUT – if Agnes keeps helping Jake research “cases” for the Bookshelf Battle Blog, wouldn’t Agnes one day be curious enough to take a peak at the Bookshelf Battle Blog and therefore, read Jake’s tales of stuff that happened to him long, long ago?
THUS – I’m not sure how I’ll handle this. Right now, I’m leaning toward the possibility that:
- Agnes checks out the BB Blog.
- Agnes does read Jake’s stories that happen long ago.
- Agnes assumes either a) Jake’s a nut (like she already does) or b) Jake’s just a modern day 35 year old and he’s just really into historical fiction and roleplaying and enjoys it so much that he walks around in a fedora and trenchcoat.
BUT – Will Jake openly share his “secret” with people?
OPTION 1 – Yes. After all, Ma Hatcher taught him never to tell a lie. He’ll wander LA, openly telling people he’s 95 years old and slept for 60 years without reservation. Most people won’t believe him, but at least he didn’t lie.
OPTION 2 – No. Best to keep it hush hush. Yes, I, Jake, do claim to be 95 years old on the blog, but that’s just for fun, don’t believe it.
Either way, most people Jake meets in modern times will not believe it.
WHAT ABOUT FUTURE MODERN WORLD CHARACTERS JAKE WILL MEET?
Remember that story, The Wrong Guy, I half finished?
I decided it was too early for all the revelations in that, and to hold off.
SPOILER ALERT:
BUT – I hope that story will end with Jake meeting a female present day LA police detective.
Remember how Jake took out a few drug dealers?
The female detective will look at Jake as an off-kilter vigilante and start watching him, looking for a way to bring Jake in. More and more, Jake will start using his private dick powers to help modern day people.
So, yeah. Jake’s kinda like Batman. And the female detective will kinda be like the cops that think Batman’s a menace.
Or maybe Jake’s not like Batman. Maybe Jake’s honest to everyone about his powers and no one believes him.
It’d be like if Bruce Wayne were to walk around shouting, “I’m Batman!” and everyone’s like, “That’s impossible! Stop lying, Bruce.”
(Will Jake and the female detective ever come to an understanding and work together? Your guess is as good as mine).
BUT – I guess, like AGNES, the question will be, will the female cop, after reading the BB Blog to find out more about Jake, believe Jake is 95 or just assume he’s crazy or writing fiction?
OTHER ISSUES:
- INVINCIBILITY – In the Wrong Guy, (there’s already some posts that show it) we learn that in modern times, Jake doesn’t just not age. He’s invincible. Shoot him. Stab him. Toss him off a building. Whatever. Jake still keeps ticking. Note in the past, from 1920 (his birth) to 1955 ( his nap) he was mortal and could have been killed, but now he can’t. It’s all part of the mystery that we HOPE Bookshelf Q. Battler will reveal once the 100 mysteries are solved.
- HOW TO HANDLE THAT – It’s the blog issue all over again. If Jake writes about his invincibility on the blog, won’t characters read about it? Will Jake just be honest and tell them, “Yup, I’m invincible” will he hide it or will characters just assume he’s lying until they somehow see it happen ( They witness Jake get shot and get back up and are like, oh ok, Jake’s not lying.)
- BB Blog vs. PCM Blog – Once I write the rough draft of the first season here on the BB blog, I’ll rewrite it, revise it, and then start posting it on the PCM Blog. So should I not refer to BB Blog and just have Delilah recruit Jake to work for the PCM blog? I actually think I should just start the season with a note that this all started on the bookshelf battle blog, this is how Jake solved a bunch of mysteries for the bb blog at first, and then work it into the story (I start to in Informant Zero) that Jake will be shifting to the PCM blog. So the first season will be about how Jake moved from BB to PCM.
- AGNES – Do you guys like the Agnes character? I’m toying with the idea that she eventually leaves the library and becomes Jake’s secretary. On the PCM blog, she might get a regular column where she promotes indie authors by listing five-ten indie books she’d like to see in her library. (Of course, then she can’t become Jake’s secretary, she’ll have to stay at the library.
SO HOW THE HELL WILL JAKE FUNCTION IN THE MODERN WORLD?
Eventually, Jake’s going to need:
- Money – And more than BQB’s cheap-o $5 bucks a case. Per Delilah’s suggestion, Jake will have to start looking for actual, REAL mystery having clients who pay a lot more than $5. Ms. Tsang can’t carry Jake’s ass forever.
- Papers – Jake’s 95 years old. His driver’s license, documents, etc., they’re all 60 years old. Maybe Ms. Donnelly can work some of her legal magic to get Jake recognized as an actual citizen…which will require them to show he was born in 1981! (Hell, maybe that’s a job for an Informant Zero).
AND FINALLY, WRAP YOUR HEAD AROUND THIS ONE….
- If Jake was an infamous lawman in the 1940s and 50’s
- Then surely, like Elliot Ness and other famous crimefighters, news articles were written about him.
- Those articles probably printed his picture at the time.
- And that picture will look like Jake now.
- So if a) Jake tries to not let people in on the secret that he’s 95 OR if people refuse to believe it even though he’s up front about it:
- Then how do we reconcile this?
I’M LEANING TOWARDS – People have a habit of explaining away the supernatural. That bump in the night isn’t a ghost. It’s your house settling.
(Calm down! It’s not really a ghost! Sheesh!)
OPTIONS:
- If Jake hides his secret, he tells people who ask about the resemblance to past Jake that he’s the grandson of infamous 40s 50s lawman Jake Hatcher and was named after him.
- But I think I’m leaning towards Jake just is open and honest to everyone that he’s 95 and if they don’t believe it, that’s their problem. Because people are quick to rationalize the supernatural, these people, like Agnes or the female detective, might just write the resemblance off as a coincidence.
- Maybe Delilah goes behind Jake’s back and tells them “Hey, yeah, Jake’s really the grandson of Jake Hatcher from long ago and he just likes to play pretend.”
I dunno. Many possibilities there.
What I’m realizing is when you move from an idea to actual publication, so, so many loose ends pile up then you have to tie up.
Maybe that’s why so many aspiring novelists quit. Every new plot point raises more questions to be answered.
But I don’t want to quit.
BUT WAIT A MINUTE, DOESN’T THE BOOKSHELF BATTLE BLOG ONLY HAVE 3.5 READERS?
Yes. I’m also thinking maybe it’s possible to completely, totally, and utterly WIPE OUT all my above worries by plugging in the following joke somewhere into the season:
JAKE: Ms. Donnelly, I don’t get it. I’ve publicly written on the Bookshelf Battle Blog that I’m 95 years old, that I was once a famous lawman, and that I took a 60 year nap. Why doesn’t anyone I meet ever ask me about that?
DELILAH: Because no one ever reads the Bookshelf Q. Battle Blog, Mr. Hatcher. It only has 3.5 readers.
JAKE: Well, what do you know? I’m hiding in plain sight!
If I go that route – NO ONE bothers to read the BB Blog because it’s so obscure. Agnes never reads it. The female detective never reads it. They wonder why Jake looks like Jake Hatcher from the 40s and 50s, and Jake tells them he’s his grandson, and because the blog only has 3.5 readers, Jake’s secrets are safe.
Of course, that’ll only work for the first season, and then the joke will have to transfer to the PCM Blog and become that Pop Culture Mysteries only has 3.5 readers, or that anything BQB is involved in is cursed to only have 3.5 readers.
OK then. Thanks 3.5. Your feedback is appreciated.
Images courtesy of a shutterstock.com license.
Copyright BQB all rights reserved 2015



